How to compare bank products with bundled discounts on a like-for-like basis
To compare products with bundled discounts like for like, fix the same operation for every bank, read two prices from each (with no discount and with all of them), record what each discount requires and what it costs to meet, and compare the two readings separately. Putting one bank’s discounted APR in the same column as another’s undiscounted APR is the most common mistake. On 28 October 2026, the median fixed-rate mortgage across 22 institutions was 4.567% APR without discounts and 3.95% with all of them: a difference of 0.62 pp.
Why are products with bundled discounts hard to compare?
Each bank builds its price its own way: a starting rate and discounts for paying in a salary, taking out insurance, using the card or contributing to a pension plan. Discounts, minimum amounts and products vary from bank to bank, and the discounted APR each one publishes rests on an example with its own assumptions (borrower’s age, sum insured, premium). Two discounted APRs may not be comparable even when the numbers look it.
What is the difference between a requirement, a discount and a tied product?
| Concept | What it is | Example | How to treat it in the comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Requirement | A condition without which there is no product or price. | A deposit for new money only; an account that requires a minimum salary paid in. | Recorded as an access condition. If the reference customer does not meet it, the product is left out for that profile. |
| Discount | An optional rate reduction in exchange for taking out or using something. | A rate reduction for paying in a salary or taking out home insurance. | Record the reduction and what it requires. All of them together give the "with discounts" reading. |
| Tied product | What has to be taken out or kept to get the discount. | Life insurance, home insurance, pension plan, card. | Record its cost when the bank publishes it; if not, say so. |
What steps does a like-for-like comparison follow?
- Fix the operation: amount, term, customer profile and use. In the mortgages observatory we use €150,000 over 25 years, 80% loan-to-value, primary residence, new customer.
- Take one figure per institution and reading: the lowest offer the bank publishes for that operation in lending, the highest in savings.
- Read two prices: with no discount and meeting every discount the bank offers. Intermediate combinations are recorded but not mixed with the other two.
- Record each discount with its reduction, what it requires (amounts, number of direct debits, minimum stay) and the tied product.
- Price the tie-in when the bank publishes it: the insurance premium in the example, the card fee, the minimum plan contribution.
- Compare each reading separately: the position without discounts, the position with all of them and each bank’s maximum reduction.
- Keep the document and date behind every figure: the product page, the fee schedule or the European Standardised Information Sheet (ESIS) it comes from.
How much do discounts weigh in mortgages today?
| Rate type | Without discounts | With every discount | Difference | Institutions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed | 4.567% | 3.95% | −0.62 pp | 22 |
| Variable | 4.76% | 4.23% | −0.53 pp | 21 |
| Mixed | 4.34% | 3.941% | −0.40 pp | 18 |
Same loan for every institution: €150,000 over 25 years, 80% loan-to-value, primary residence, new customer. One figure per institution: its lowest offer.
In deposits the effect is smaller and works the other way: conditions raise the return. At 12 months, the median goes from 1.755% without conditions to 1.91% meeting them (31 institutions), according to the term deposits observatory.
Does the discounted APR already include the cost of tied products?
Partly. The discounted APR banks publish usually includes, in its representative example, the cost of the tied products the bank itself declares, for instance an insurance premium for a borrower of a given age. Since each bank chooses its own assumptions, read the example before comparing and, where assumptions differ, also compare the borrowing rate and the reduction each discount gives.
What are the most common mistakes?
- Mixing readings: one bank’s discounted APR next to another’s undiscounted APR.
- Comparing different operations: another amount, term or loan-to-value changes the pricing band.
- Forgetting when the discount applies: some only count from the second year or only in the variable period.
- Ignoring minimum amounts: a high minimum salary leaves many customers out.
- Taking the figure from the advert instead of the document, or not keeping the date.
How does Baremo do it?
Baremo stores every discount and requirement as a structured condition, with its reduction and what it requires, and computes both readings for each product from the bank’s documents. That is how they appear in the mortgages and term deposits observatories. To see your bank measured this way against its competitors, request the free audit.
Frequently asked questions
How do you compare bank products with bundled discounts across different banks on a like-for-like basis?
With the same operation for all of them, two price readings per bank (without discounts and with all of them), each discount recorded with what it requires and what it costs, and each reading compared separately. Every figure with its document and date.
Which APR should be used to compare mortgages with discounts?
Both, separately: the APR without discounts shows the starting price and the APR with all of them the best possible price. Mixing them in one column gives a misleading comparison.
How do you compare a deposit that requires paying in a salary?
As an access requirement: compare it in the "with conditions" reading and record the minimum amount, because it leaves out customers who do not meet it.
Can it be summed up in a single number per bank?
You can compute a total cost for a specific customer by adding the price and the cost of tied products, but it depends so much on assumptions that it is best shown alongside the two readings, not instead of them.
See your market under the same yardstick.
A demo takes thirty minutes with your competitor set. We come with the questions your committee asked last week.